Selecting the right saddle for your bike and needs can be a bit of a minefield. Throw into the mix you being a larger rider, and this can make searching for a saddle even more tricky.

We as humans come in all different shapes and sizes, and require different products to help us get the most out of our cycling. However, it doesn’t have to be difficult to find the perfect saddle for you.

Best Bike Saddles for Heavy Riders [Male] [Female]

Do Overweight People Need Special Bike Seats?

If you’re on the heavier side of the average weight, then you may feel you need a more specialist saddle for your bike to feel comfortable and properly supported.

Additionally, if you are wider in the derrière, you may also feel that you’d prefer a wider saddle to feel comfier and get more out of your riding. But all in all, it’s down to personal preference at the end of the day – only you know your body and its needs.

Max. Weight for Standard Bicycle Seat

The maximum weight of a standard bicycle saddle is not something that is largely reported on, annoyingly. However, bikes overall do often have a weight limit, for safety as well as warranty reasons.

These weight limits do depend on the type of bike (and therefore saddle), as some bikes have a more generous weight limit than others. But it is usually between 190lbs (folding bike) to 400lbs (fat bike and electric bike).

Therefore if you fit within these weights you shouldn’t have any issues, but it is always best to check.

Male vs Female Bicycle Seats

Bicycle saddles are designed to be unisex and suit either types of nether regions, as obviously both differ hugely, and therefore require different features to ensure comfort and support.

Classically female orientated saddles tend to be wider, due to women typically having wider hips. They have cut outs (holes) to relieve any soft tissue pressure to prevent numbness and pain.

More male orientated saddles tend to be slightly narrower, and without a cut out in the middle.

Bike Seats for Heavy Riders [KEY FEATURES]

Bike saddles for riders who are heavier will often feature more padding, offer a wider area to sit on (especially where your sit bones are) and often have more solid, thicker saddle railings.

Best Bike Seat for Overweight Men [Top 3]

1. Brand-X Cruiser Saddle [REVIEW]
2. Brooks England B17 Short Bike Saddle [REVIEW]
3. Cloud-9 Bicycle Suspension Cruiser Saddle [REVIEW]

Click here to see the best bike seats for heavy women

1. Brand-X Cruiser Saddle

• £15
• $15
• €20

Prices are approximate

Nice and wide (269mm x 256mm)

Great coil sprung suspension system

Super affordable

The Brand-X Cruiser Saddle offers great support thanks to it’s wide dimensions (269mm x 256mm), which is supported on strong steel rails and coupled up with a useful coil sprung suspension system to ensure total comfort while riding. Not only this, but it’s super affordable, making it a great ‘buy to try’ purchase for any heavier rider looking for a comfy saddle. So, what are you waiting for?

Pros

• Strong and reliable Steel Rails
• Very well priced
• Features suspension

Cons

• Heavy (1012g)

buy here

2. Brooks England B17 Short Bike Saddle

• £100
• $110
• €120

Prices are approximate

The leather wears into you

Not compromising aesthetically

Very high quality

If you’re looking for a super stylish saddle that’s made from leather to wear into your body over time, but still support a larger rider, then this is the one. The Brooks England B17 Short Bike Saddle is wide enough at 176mm to support most male behinds, and with its lack of padding suits a typical male preference to have a studier less squishy saddle. This would also be perfect on a vintage looking fixie or city bike.

Pros

• Wears into your body over time
• Super stylish
• Wide fit for a Brooks (176mm)

Cons

• Have to break it in (leather)
• No padding

buy here

3. Cloud-9 Bicycle Suspension Cruiser Saddle

• £60
• $80
• €70

Prices are approximate

Offers lots of foam padding

Very wide for support (266.7mm x 266.7)

features chrome coil spring suspension

This large saddle offers a lot more in the way of gel foam padding, compared to the previous selection. Not only does this saddle come with a generous amount of padding, but the saddle also features coil spring suspension: pair this with the fact it’s also a very wide saddle at 266.7mm and you have a very decent level of comfort. All in all, this saddle would be great for a larger rider who wants large amounts of padding and width.

Pros

• Very well padded
• Offers some suspension
• Very wide

Cons

• Made from synthetic

SHOP ON AMAZON

Best Bike Seat for Overweight Female [Top 3]

1. Selle Italia T2 Gel Flow City Saddle

• £45
• $80
• €55

Prices are approximate

Made from gel padding

Nice and thick

Very wide (233x258mm)

If you’re in the market for a thick gel saddle then the Selle Italia T2 Gel Flow City Saddle is for you. This wide saddle helps to support your derrière thanks to generous measurements of 233x258mm. This saddle also features a cut out in the middle to relieve any potential numbness. It’s a really solid option for female riders looking for a comfy, supportive saddle for longer rides.

Pros

• Thick gel padding
• Very wide
• Solid levels of support

Cons

• Doesn’t specify max weight

buy here

2. YBEKI Bicycle Saddle

• £35
• $40
• €40

Prices are approximate

Offers great level of support

Very very wide

Made from memory foam

If a very very wide saddle is what you have been searching far and wide (pardon the pun) for, then your search thankfully ends here. The YBEKI saddle offers a very impressive level of support thanks to it being so wide. Not only that, but the padding is also made of memory foam to help support your undercarriage and ensure you’re comfortable. A fab option for anyone needing a very wide saddle for their bike.

Pros

• Very wide
• Made memory foam
• Doesn’t impede on pedalling

Cons

• Outer not vegan (leather)

buy here

3. Specialized The Cup Gel

• £50
• $50
• €55

Prices are approximate

Part of Specialized Body Geometry range

Gel padding

Wide saddle at 245mm

One of Specialized’s best selling saddles in their US market, The Cup Gel offers a great level of comfort thanks to its generous gel padding. Not only that, but the saddle also measures up at 245mm at the back, making it a lot wider than your average saddle It ensures you feel supported and comfortable no matter what your size. A solid option to put on your hybrid or city bike.

Pros

• Wide
• Specialized body geometry design
• Great for larger riders

Cons

• Only available in one colour

buy here

The post Most Comfortable Bike Seat for Overweight Riders: The 6 Best appeared first on Discerning Cyclist.

I run cycling sessions for women, and the most commonly asked questions are always about saddles.

Usually the women in question are new to riding, and experiencing discomfort. Sometimes they’re more experienced cyclists who are keen to switch from the standard issue saddle that came with their bike. Or maybe they’re commuters who want to avoid having to wear padded clothing on their way to work.

Whatever the reason, the reality is that saddles can hurt and saddle sore can be a particular barrier to women cycling.

However, in the past few years the cycling sector has become increasingly aware of this issue, thanks to high profile athletes like Hannah Dines speaking about having to undergo reconstructive vulva surgery, and well known cycling journalist Orla Chennauoi writing this taboo breaking ‘The V word – why we need to talk about saddle discomfort‘ article for Rouleur.

More women feel able to openly talk about their saddle experiences, and it has become normalised to raise and discuss from commuter cycling to elite level.

As a result, manufacturers who have previously focused on prioritising saddle design and ergonomics for the male body are now making sure they’re also catering for the female anatomy. This is a welcome change in the industry, but every body and bike is different, so it is important to know what saddle would work for you.

What to Look for in a Women’s Bicycle Seat

We’ve established that women’s bicycle seats differ to their counterparts for men but we need to understand why and how, so you know what to look for in your saddle.

The main difference is linked to our sit bones. As the name suggests, these are the bones that take your weight when sitting as they are located at the bottom of your pelvis. Women typically tend to have wider sit bones as our hips are wider for childbirth. Our saddles should therefore reflect this, by being wider at the back.

Don’t use your clothes size as a guide for size. Your local bike shop may have a special measuring tool, but if not, you can also do it at home by watching this quick video from renowned saddle manufacturer Selle.

Once you’ve established these measurements, check out your chosen saddle’s sizing guide to pick the right one for you as they can vary.

The next thing to consider is how you usually sit on your bike when cycling. Adopting a more ‘aggressive’ riding position of being lower means you may experience more soft tissue discomfort as your body is bent forwards. In this case you should look for a flat saddle with a short ‘nose’ design and large pressure relief area.

If you ride in a more upright position then you’ll benefit from having a more curved and longer bike seat with padding at the rear as your body weight will be more centred towards the back of the saddle. Gel padded saddles are often seen as a solution for this riding style and they can work for short and infrequent use, but over time they can distort and lose their shape.

Although a saddle with firmer padding made from material like leather may need to be broken in, this will pay off – especially if you ride regularly.

We’ve already referenced soft tissue and in addition to saddle shape, there are other features that can help to reduce discomfort. Women have much greater variety and also sensitivity when it comes to our soft tissue.

Like belly buttons, many women find they fall into what is known as an ‘innie’ or an ‘outie’ category. Female specific saddles can therefore have a design element called ‘cut outs’ to address this, especially for those who consider themselves to be ‘outies’. Basically cut outs are are gaps and/or grooves in the saddle design to relieve pressure on your soft tissue.

If possible, it’s always useful to try before you buy so you get an idea of what saddles will be best for you. For example, there are excellent initiatives out there like the amazing women led London Bike Kitchen’s Saddle Library where you can borrow and test out a range of options.

To help you decide, we have researched and drawn on our lived experience to put together the below helpful list of the top 6 best bike seats for women.

Why You Can Trust Us

Discerning Cyclist’s expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing cycling products so you don’t have to.

Testing stylish gear since 2012

Hundreds of hands-on product tests

Unfiltered opinions from experienced cyclists

Learn more about Discerning Cyclist here.

Best Bike Seats for Women [Top 6]

1. Specialized Power Comp with Mimic [REVIEW]
2. Selle Italia Diva Gel Flow Bike Saddle [REVIEW]
3. Brooks B17 Short [REVIEW]
4. Brand X Women’s Comfort Cut Out Saddle [REVIEW]
5. Selle Italia SLR Lady Flow Saddle [REVIEW]
6. Brooks B67 [REVIEW]

1. Specialized Power Comp with Mimic

Price (approximate):

• £95
• $112
• €108

High tech

Available in 3 sizes

Multi-layered materials

This is a popular women’s saddle with rave reviews. We are big fans as not only is it number one in this list, but it was also named as our best bike saddle for female commuters in our compilation of the most comfortable bike seats for women.

Specialized are taking the issues that women face when it comes to saddles seriously, so much so that they have created patented MIMIC technology to produce a saddle that “perfectly adapts to your body to give you the support you need”.

This has been achieved by using multi-layered materials to provide padding but also reduce any potential swelling.

On top of this, their outstanding Body Geometry design boosts blood flow to that all important soft tissue.

Available in three different sizes and at a fairly reasonable price, this is our top choice.

2. Selle Italia Diva Gel Flow Bike Saddle

Price (approximate):

• £114
• $135
• €131

‘Superflow’ cut out

Dense foam padding

Leather cover

Selle are very well established in the world of saddles. Handmade in Italy, they have designed this saddle specifically to make cycling comfortable for women and the female anatomy.

Available in two different widths of 135mm and 152mm, it incorporates a light gel and a large central cut out to relieve pressure in sensitive areas, particularly around the perineum.

The saddle shape is streamlined and sporty to cater for commuting, and also longer leisure rides.

3. Brooks B17 Short

Price (approximate):

• £135
• $159
• €154

Shorter nose

Made from durable leather

10 year guarantee

Brooks are well known and respected for making high quality and long lasting saddles that are handmade in England. Their best selling B17 model is designed for women, and this specific model has a shorter nose.

Optimised for commuting and a 60 degree angled riding position, this saddle will mould and shape to you over time making it comfortable and also durable thanks to the use of 100% vegetable tanned leather.

Available in three different colours of black, brown and honey, you can also choose between softened and carved versions of this model.

Inevitably this level of bespoke quality comes at a cost so Brooks saddles are an investment but they are worth it, and their long life span means you can also find good quality second hand options.

4. Brand X Women’s Comfort Cut Out Saddle

Price (approximate):

• £15
• $17
• €17

Durable waterproof cover

Strong and reliable rails

Comfortable shape

Coming in at the lowest priced saddle in this list, Brand X Women’s Comfort Cut Out Saddle aims to provide support at a much more accessible price point.

Although it is only available in one size, the lightweight but high density padding means it’ll be a comfortable seat to ride on.

The long central cut out will also relieve soft tissue pressure while cycling.

Its versatile design means it is perfect for all kinds of cycling and as it won’t break the bank, it is also a good option to test out before potentially upgrading to a higher end alternative if needs be.

5. Selle Italia SLR Lady Flow Saddle

Price (approximate):

• £117
• $139
• €134

Two size options

Durable cover

Large cut out and padding

Another Selle saddle has made the list. Again, it has also been specifically designed for women.

It may only be a saddle but it is full of clever technology including a carbon fibre shell, a highly resistant and durable cover material and their new SuperFlow cutout. This means it is light weight but strong.

Comfort is also a priority as the cut out allows women of different sizes to find a riding position that works for them. It also prevents prolonged pressure on your pelvis so it is perfect for all kinds of cycling, including your commute.

6. Brooks B67

Price (approximate):

• £145
• $171
• €165

Durable leather

Shapes over time

10 year guarantee

Our second Brooks saddle and the final suggestion in our list, the B67, is a leather saddle for city or touring.

Suggested as the saddle for city bikes, Dutch style bikes, cargo bikes and touring bicycles, it is ideal for women who ride in an upright position.

It is similar in shape to the other Brooks saddle we’ve featured but this model comes with chromed suspension springs for ultimate comfort.

It is also available in three colours – black, brown and honey, as well as a short and softened version too.

The post Best Bike Seats for Women: Top 6 Saddles for Female Commuters appeared first on Discerning Cyclist.

The Short Answer

The height of your bike seat, or saddle, is important for comfort and performance. A rough estimate is to align it with your hip while standing next to the bike. Alternatively, you can use a bike seat height chart based on your inseam measurement for a more accurate adjustment.

You may be searching google right now trying to figure out where you should adjust your saddle to on a bike you’ve borrowed or never ridden before, wondering where the right place to have it is.

Well, you’ ha’ve come to the right place. Without confusing jargon or condescending opinions about what you should or shouldn’t do, we can offer some solid advice on what you may find comfortable and suitable for your own personal needs. 

Does Bike Seat Height Matter? 

The height of your saddle is so important when it comes to riding a bike. This is because if a saddle is too high, then you may not be able to adequately pedal, nor be able to control the bike very well.

The latter issue of course is a safety concern, as no one wants to feel out of control or crash their bike. Therefore it’s important for your own safety to know the correct saddle height for you.

Having a suitable height will also help to improve your comfort levels while riding. Given that bicycle saddles are known for not always being the comfiest, this is very important for your enjoyment.

Having your saddle at the correct height for you will also mean that you get the most out of your power. This may or may not be something you’re concerned about, but overall it’s important that you’re more efficient while riding your bike, as it arguably helps you to pedal further, for longer.

Bike Seat Height [Rule of Thumb]

If you’re in a rush and panicking because you don’t have a tape measure on you, but need to adjust a saddle height (maybe you’re hiring a bike to get around a city) then don’t panic.

Yes a tape measure would be useful! However, there are other ways to can figure out a suitable saddle height for your bike.

Should Your Bike Seat Be at Your Hip? 

As many people have heard throughout the years, having your saddle height roughly in line with your hip, while standing next to your bike with your feet flat on the floor, is a pretty standard estimate.

Does it work? Arguably, yes. It’s a good enough way to try to determine how high you need your saddle. However, it’s important to note that some bikes have a higher bottom bracket (where your crank fits into).

This higher bottom bracket can mean that this method can put your saddle height too low, as the higher bottom bracket means you need a slightly higher than your hip saddle.

But, by all means try it out as it may be something that works for you. If you’re in a rush and need a rough guide or starting point, then this tip can be a solid one to follow. 

How to Tell if Bike Seat is Too High 

If your saddle on your bike is too high for you, you may notice at first that you can’t pedal very well once the pedal or crank arm is at its lowest position while turning. If you find at this point you can’t put your foot on the pedal, then your saddle is too high.

As well as not being able to reach the pedals while in this position, you may also notice that your hips ‘rock’ while riding along. This is due to your saddle being too high, thus your hips move side to side to try to reach your pedals. 

If you’ve been riding the bike for a while and you are unsure, sometimes lower back pain can also be an indicator that your saddle is too high. Also, you may notice soreness from your saddle due to the way a higher saddle positions you.

How to Tell if Bike Seat is Too Low 

If you want to tell if your saddle is too low, a good starting point is if you can be sat on your saddle and have your feet flat on the floor at the same time. If this is the case, your saddle is too low. 

Another tell tale sign that your saddle is too low is you may feel a little cramped on your bike. You may not realise that this cramped feeling is your saddle height, but if you feel the need to stretch out your legs while pedalling, then it could be a sign the saddle is too low.

Additionally, you may also find you have knee pain from constantly having your knee very bent while riding your bike. 

Another sign is that you don’t feel like you’re fully utilising your power. You may feel that with every pedal stroke you could put out more power and feel something is restricted. This can be due to needing to pull your seat post up.

Bike Seat Height Chart 

If you do happen to have a little more time and a tape measure to hand, then there are more effective ways to work out the correct saddle height for you. 

The best way would be to measure your inseam (inside of your leg) and then matching your inseam measurement roughly to the recommended saddle height, measured from the middle of your crank to the top of the saddle. 

Here’s the table:

The post Bike Seat Height Chart: THE EASY GUIDE appeared first on Discerning Cyclist.

The Short Answer

Bike seats can hurt due to factors like bruised sit bones, chafing, and skin irritation. Standard saddles may not fit everyone, and finding the right saddle is important. Padded shorts and saddle covers can help. Pain diminishes with time, and gender-specific and comfortable saddle options are available.

Although cycling is a fantastic pastime, a way to keep fit and mode of transport many people will find at some point, they develop pain in their nether regions due to their saddle and the many issues they can unfortunately cause you.

Butt (apologies I just couldn’t help myself) we no longer live in the olden times when saddles were just made from leather and metal without much variation: these days there’s a lot on the market regarding saddles and other products to help ease any issues that may arise. 

Saddle Soreness: Bike Seat Hurts Butt

Many of you, if not all reading this, will at some point have experienced soreness from being on a bike saddle. This soreness can be a result of: bruised sit bones (the bones in your bottom), chafing which can cause skin irritation or damage, or saddle sores which are basically wounds or spots.

First and foremost, bruised sit bones are often caused by not being used to a saddle, so a little discomfort here can be expected when ‘bedding in’ a new saddle. But you should actually measure your sit bones before purchasing a saddle to ensure the width at the back is the nearest size to your measurement. 

Next, chafing is a pretty common and self explanatory one. It occurs due to the material of your clothing and saddle rubbing together. It’s annoying but there are a few products like padded shorts and chamois cream that, alongside a saddle that suits your body, will help to prevent chafing from happening as much. 

Skin irritation and damage is a nasty one, that can occur from sitting on a saddle for a long time. The best way to stop this is having a comfortable saddle, as well as wearing breathable clothing while riding. Some irritation may still occur if you have sensitive skin though, but sometimes you have to just allow your nether regions to get used to it.

Are Bike Seats Supposed to Hurt?

Saddles on bikes are not meant to hurt you. But the problem is, when a bike has been sold, a standard saddle is fitted to the bike: often an easy and cheap to manufacture generic one. This saddle may suit you, however, chances are it doesn’t.

The most important thing to remember is that humans come in all different shapes and sizes and therefore this variation means one size definitely does not fit all. So it’s important to factor in the cost of a new saddle when budgeting for a bike.

Therefore, if you saddle is hurting and you are really struggling, it’s best to pop along to a local bike store and see if you can have a saddle fitted to you (saddle mapping as it’s often called) to help ease your pain.

It’s also worth noting that many bike shops will let you try a saddle out or bike a saddle to try for 30 days and then give you a full refund if it’s unsuitable. So make sure you look out for this being offered, as it’s well worth considering.

Why Do Bike Seats Hurt?

Saddles can hurt mainly due to two reasons: you may not be used to it or the saddle design itself is just not suited to your anatomy, nor your personal needs. 

That being said, if you have found the correct saddle you should not be experiencing too much pain. A little numbness every now and then may occur, especially if you are sat on the edge of your saddle or in a position you don’t normally sit in as it may reduce blood flow (hence the numbness). 

However, a good saddle that is suited to your needs as well as a pair of padded shorts that are also suited to your anatomy will be a solid coupling to help prevent any pain that may occur. Although, if you are riding for hours on end, a little pain may still be expected.

Bicycle Seat Pain: Male vs Female 

Some saddles on the market are designed to be male or female sex specific. This is because the difference in anatomy means a slight adjustment in design is needed in order to promote blood flow and relieve delicate tissue where needed.

Meanwhile, some saddles are very cleverly designed to suit the needs of both sexes in order to effectively support and relieve pressure points to reduce pain. 

Why Are Bike Seats So Uncomfortable?

Bike saddles are often so uncomfortable because the saddles that come as standard on bikes have not had much technology or research put into them: they’re often cheap and easy to mass produce. 

Thus they often aren’t as comfy or specialist. On the other hand, some people get on really well with cheaper saddles, it is massively down to the individual and their own personal needs. 

It’s also arguably due to the fact that humans just are not designed to put a lot of pressure, or their body weight, on such a delicate part of their body such as their undercarriage. So there’s no real surprise that saddles can hurt. 

Does Bike Seat Pain Go Away?

Luckily, if you are just getting into cycling, the great news is that the pain does eventually subside as your body gets used to being sat on a saddle. The rate in which this occurs will differ slightly for everyone.

In general, riding your bike as often and as much as you can will help your body to get used to sitting on your saddle pain free. Your undercarriage will also become more in tune to your saddle and the position you are in while on your bike. 

How Do I Make My Bike Seat More Comfortable? 

If you want to make your saddle more comfortable and the pains go away faster, as mentioned previously, there are certain steps that can be taken in order to ensure maximum comfort.

For example, a very well padded saddle or alternatively a saddle cover, which is a great and inexpensive way to make your saddle more comfortable. These often just offer extra gel or foam padding which is easily attached on top of the existing saddle. 

Or of course, getting yourself a pair of padded shorts which can be worn under pretty much anything – just remember to ditch the underwear while wearing them for optimal effect. Sounds bizarre, I know, but it really does make them much more comfier. 

Padded Bike Seat Covers

On the other hand, if you’re looking just for a good saddle cover to improve the current saddle you have instead of splashing out on a new one, there are a lot of solid options to choose from.

For example, a good quality one from Selle Italia can be purchased from the popular British retailer Halfords, which is water resistant, perfect for commuters and affordable. It also comes in S, M and L to suitably fit it over your current saddle. 

Most Comfortable Bike Saddles 

Below are just a small selection of saddles that within the cycling industry and due to the technology used to design them, are widely regarded as some of the most comfortable saddles on the market.

They may not suit you but they are a great starting point and definitely good options to try if you are on the lookout for a comfy saddle.

Best Women’s Saddle

1. Specialized Power Comp with MIMIC

• £100
• $140

Prices are approximate

Patented Body Geometry design is lab-tested to ensure blood flow to sensitive arteries

Innovative MIMIC technology uses multilayered materials to maintain equilibrium and minimise swelling in soft tissue.

Durable hollow Cr-Mo rails.

Level 2 padding: Medium density foam for bike feel with additional cushioning.

Available in three widths: 143mm, 155mm and 168m.

This women’s specific saddle from Specialized is a great choice for women who have had a hard time finding the right saddle. Although it may look more like a road bike saddle, it’s actually a popular option among commuters and leisure riders too.

Thanks to its special foam-like technology at the front (nose) of the saddle helps to cushion the soft tissue, helping to prevent swelling as well as pain. Therefore it’s understandable why it’s been such a big hit with female cyclists.

buy here

2. Specialized Power Expert

• £115
• $160

Prices are approximate

Patented Body Geometry design is lab-tested for both men and women to assure blood flow to sensitive arteries.

Lightweight and supportive PU padding for comfort and support on longer rides.

Lightweight and durable hollow titanium rails.

Tough, lightweight, and water-resistant cover.

Available in four widths: 130mm, 143mm, 155mm and 168mm.

A similar design to the previous offering, but designed specifically to suit both male and female saddle needs, this is another great offering from Specialized that is great for every kind of cyclist, from commuters, to road riders, and gravel explorers.

Interestingly, this saddle has a gap in the middle to offer relief for your delicate soft tissue / undercarriage to help promote blood flow as well as preventing numbness – leaving you able to enjoy your ride in total comfort.

buy here

3. Bontrager Boulevard Fluid Bike Saddle

• £80
• $80

Prices are approximate

Fluid adds comfort by moving with you as you pedal to alleviate pressure

Fluid is better than gel at reducing pressure, showing an average reduction of over 20% in peak pressure compared to gel alone.

Full cut-out provides targeted support and soft-tissue relief.

 

Dual-density shell and air foam construction is soft yet supportive.

Available in two sizes: 280mm x 205mm and 280mm x 225mm

Last but not least, a cheaper and more stereotypically looking ‘comfortable’ saddle that still offers similar features to the previous two with a little extra padding. However, this saddle possesses a patented technology that allows the saddle to move freely with you as you pedal for less pressure and more comfort.

Overall this saddle offers a great amount of padding and support which will help reduce any sit bone soreness that you may be experiencing. Equally, due to the cut out in the middle, numbness and soft tissue discomfort will also be minimised. Therefore, this is a solid selection for commuters and leisure riders.

buy here

The post Saddle Soreness: Why Do Bike Seats Hurt (and How to Stop It)? appeared first on Discerning Cyclist.

Brooks saddles are universally regarded as some of the best saddles available anywhere in the world. That makes them an attractive proposition for most cyclists, even more so if you use your bicycle for the daily commute. Finding the right saddle for everyday use is hugely important.

Read on as we break down the best Brooks saddles for commuting.

How Do I Choose a Brooks Saddle?

Brooks saddles have earned a reputation for being top of their class. The company has a storied history and has been building saddles since 1886! Choosing the right Brooks saddle comes down to a range of factors including riding style, usage and personal preference.

Making the right decision with a Brooks saddle is especially important because they sit at the higher end of the price bracket. Their robust leather construction also means that they’ll last a long time; at least 10 years but probably much longer.

They mould to your body shape over time, giving you a personalised saddle that many cyclists are reluctant to part with. They’re a lifelong investment, so prior research is vital.

Are Brooks Saddles Good for Long Rides?

Brooks saddles are excellent for long rides. The secret lies in the leather construction. Although they might look uncomfortable (and these saddles are more rigid than their rivals) the leather moulds to take your body shape over time. This makes them exceptionally comfortable.

Having what amounts to a custom made (once the leather has moulded to you it becomes unique) saddle makes long rides a breeze. Brooks saddles are also exceptionally durable and water-resistant. The B17, for example, is designed with long rides and “boundless freedom” in mind.

Depending on your riding style you can also find saddles with additional springs and even pressure-release cutouts. These features make long rides a pleasure even across bumpy terrain.

Are Brooks Saddles Good for Commuting?

Unsurprisingly, the answer to this question is a resounding yes! All the comfort features (the leather, the support and weatherproofing) that make these saddles great for long rides are equally effective on the daily commute.

In fact, many cyclists swear by Brooks for their daily commute. The all-weather nature of these saddles makes them an excellent choice: a Brooks saddle really will see you through the year. Better still, if you ride the saddle every day it will adapt to your shape quicker. It can take some time for the leather to mould to your body but using the saddle to commute speeds up the process. The result? A custom-fit saddle in no time at all!

The only slight concern with these saddles is that their high value makes them a prime target for thieves. It’s hardly a reason not to invest, but it is something to be aware of. Brooks has taken measures to make their saddles more secure, but you can go further. A simple saddle cover hides the brand name. Other cyclists prefer to detach the saddle when they park up at work.

Why You Can Trust Us

Discerning Cyclist’s expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing cycling products so you don’t have to.

Testing stylish gear since 2012

Hundreds of hands-on product tests

Unfiltered opinions from experienced cyclists

Learn more about Discerning Cyclist here.

Best Brooks England Saddles for Commuting [Top 3]

Brooks saddles are undoubtedly quality, but it still pays to be a little discerning when choosing your commuter model. Here’s a rundown of the top three choices.

1. Brooks B67

• £150
• $170
• €160

Prices are approximate

• Dimensions: L 260 x W 205 x H 73
• Weight: 850 g

Durable, 5mm Vegetable Tanned Leather

Chromed Springs and Frame Assembly

Designed for an upright riding position, the B67 will set you back a hefty price of more than £100/$150. For that price, though, you get a saddle made using premium leather, exceptional comfort, durability and a 10 year guarantee. The B67 is easily one of the best commuter saddles on the market.

The suspension strings make all the difference. They guarantee a comfortable commute even across the bumpiest of roads and ensure that you arrive at work feeling fresh and sprightly. Additional suspension is handy if you carry a lot to the office. This is the saddle to go for if you pack a heavy backpack, for example. It’s designed to work on cargo bikes, which tells you all you need to know about its load-bearing capabilities.

Although not the most expensive saddle on the list, that price tag is a clear drawback. Most Brooks hover around the £100 price point (with a few notable exceptions) so the B67 is a touch above average. Expensive as it might seem, the long-lasting nature of these leather saddles does go some way to justify their price tag.

SHOP ON AMAZON

2. Brooks C67

• £115
• $130
• €130

Prices are approximate

• Dimensions: L 268 x W 200 x H 59 mm
• Weight: 485 g

Vulcanised Natural Rubber Saddle Top

Flexible and Robust Touring Surface

The C67 is the newest and perhaps most interesting addition to the Brooks catalogue. It was designed for e-bikes and urban cycling and provides a modern twist on Brooks’ classic style.

Given the burgeoning popularity of e-bikes, it’s easy to see why Brooks went down this route. If you own an e-bike (or are considering investing) this saddle is for you.

It’s exceptionally flexible and designed to absorb bumps from the road surface. This has the effect of smoothing out any ride, making the commute a breeze. Although the C67 isn’t made from leather like Brooks’ other offerings (which might be a disappointment for some) the rubber nonetheless moves and adapts as you cycle. The rear of the saddle is slightly raised to account for sudden acceleration.

E-bikes seem on an inexorable path to taking over the commuter bike scene, so this saddle really is a no brainer. It’s a big moment when a heritage brand like Brooks embraces the future in this manner. More e-bike saddles are sure to follow soon, but in the meantime, you can’t go wrong here.

SHOP ON AMAZON

3. Brooks B33

• £180
• $220
• €200

Prices are approximate

• Dimensions: L 318 x W 235 x H 110 mm
• Weight: 1600 g

Durable, 5mm Vegetable Tanned Leather

Chromed, Stranded Springs and Frame Assembly

The Brooks B33 was designed specifically with urban cycling in mind. This makes it the perfect choice for commuting. As well as all the usual, classic stylings that you would associate with Brooks, the B33 is also the widest in the range to support a more upright cycling position.

Additional springs and support mean that it’s capable of carrying additional weight, too. That’s fantastic if you commute with a heavy rucksack and the support does make a difference. The tanned leather is extremely durable (as you’d expect from a Brooks saddle) and water runs right off. You’ll also get the standard Brooks 10 year guarantee.

We recommend the B33 for all your commuting needs, but this is a saddle designed explicitly for upright cyclists. It’s important to keep this in mind before making the big £179.99 (this is the most expensive saddle on the list) investment.

SHOP ON AMAZON

The post Best Brooks Saddles For Commuting appeared first on Discerning Cyclist.

Finding the best bike saddles for commuting is important. Apart from being uncomfortable, an ill-fitting saddle can also cause lower back problems, and can even give you a poor posture. Saddles that are too narrow don’t support the pelvis or bone structure, whereas an overly wide saddle causes the dreaded chafing.

That’s not to mention saddle sores, and a range of other rarer problems including nerve damage to the perineum. The problem is even worse on the commute, which necessarily means you’ll be on your bike every day. A poorly fitted or poorly designed saddle will wreak havoc with your body, leaving you feeling tired before you’ve even reached the office.

Finding the best bike saddle for commuting can seem like hard work, however. There are plenty on the market, ranging from budget friendly models to more expensive, premium offerings. The kind of saddle you need depends on your riding style, measurements and posture, but it’s possible to narrow down the list. Here’s a look at the best commuter saddles currently on sale.

Finding a Comfortable Bike Saddle [Key Considerations]

Given the variety of saddles available, it should come as no surprise to learn that there are lots of different factors to consider. Narrow vs wide is a common question, but you also need to think about the weight, the type of material and the shape (round, semi-round or flat).

Some saddles also come with a cutout. Whether you opt for this is a matter of personal preference but it’s designed to ease pressure on the soft tissue area. Some people also feel that cutouts help with ventilation, keeping the rider cool. Padding is another important area to consider. Although it seems logical to opt for saddles with deep padding, this isn’t always the best solution. Thick padding that compresses over time warps and puts pressure where it’s not wanted. Modern saddles tend to use strategic rather than all-over padding.

You can usually opt for extras too. Additions like reinforced corners prevent wear and some will have attachments for bags. Some saddles are designed specifically for men or women, others are unisex. Saddles should never be uncomfortable and you should never feel that you have to put up with a bit of pain or numbness. A well-chosen saddle that takes into account all of these key considerations will make riding a joy.

Narrow vs Wide Bike Saddle

Perhaps the biggest question to ask when looking for the best bike saddle for commuting is whether to go for narrow or wide. Generally speaking, wide saddles are best for people who cycle in an upright position. Narrow saddles are preferable for those with a lower riding position.

These are generalisations, though, and there’s more to saddle width than just riding position. A wider saddle is usually better for casual or commuter cycling because it offers extreme support for the pelvis and eliminates chaffing. It also minimises pressure on the thighs. Many simply consider wider saddles to be more comfortable on a casual ride.

Wider saddles do come with disadvantages though. They limit how quickly you can move your legs, making for a slower journey, and if you go too wide you’ll actually cause more chafing. Narrow saddles don’t interfere with the cycling motion so you can generate more speed. They’re also more efficient (and save energy) because they help you to maximise leg movement. Narrow saddles tend to be used by professional cyclists to extract maximum performance.

The downside to this, of course, is that many new or casual cyclists find them uncomfortable. They provide less support, and if they’re too narrow, they can even be painful. Of course, it all comes down to personal preference, but more casual commuter cyclists tend to prefer a wider saddle.

Bike Saddle Size

Deciding between a narrow/wide saddle is only part of the battle. Saddle size is extremely important because saddles are supposed to support seat bones. If the size isn’t right, then the saddle will be misaligned, and it won’t offer the same levels of support and you’ll end up feeling extremely uncomfortable.

Poor saddle sizing is the number one reason that cyclists experience discomfort as they ride. Even the best saddle from a renowned manufacturer won’t be any good if you get the sizing wrong, and it might even do longer-term damage, especially to your posture. People with badly sized saddles often find themselves walking with poor posture, or suffering from lower back pain.

What Size Bike Saddle Do I Need?

It’s easy to find the right bike size saddle with a little effort. Nearly all brands feature a wide range of sizes, and getting the right dimensions is often just a matter of measuring and then taking the saddle for a test ride.

Cycling shops have various methods for measuring the distance between your sit bones. These might involve memory foam (which moulds to your shape), some kind of gel or simply a pad. If you want to do this yourself at home you can use tin foil. Place the tinfoil on a step or stair and then sit on it, mimicking your riding position. When you stand up you’ll notice two depressions in the foil – measure the distance between the two and then add 25-30mm. That’s your saddle size.

Test rides are extremely important too. You’ll invariably be allowed to take your saddle for a ride but the duration matters. Try to cycle with the saddle for at least an hour. Some will be instantly uncomfortable, but others will take time. That’s particularly important if you plan to buy a more expensive saddle, which is a long term investment. Be sure to check whether the manufacturer offers returns or substitutions, too.

Why You Can Trust Us

Discerning Cyclist’s expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing cycling products so you don’t have to.

Testing stylish gear since 2012

Hundreds of hands-on product tests

Unfiltered opinions from experienced cyclists

Learn more about Discerning Cyclist here.

Best Bike Saddles for Commuting [Top 3]

1. Brooks B17

• £95
• $135
• €116

Prices are approximate

• Weight: 520g
• Width: 175mm
• Length: 275mm
• Height: 65mm

Premium leather – moulds to your shape over time.

Extremely high build quality

Waterproof, durable and rigid for maximum support

Brooks Saddles, of course, have a storied history and are considered some of the best in the world. Not many saddle companies can boast of a saddle that’s been popular for over 100 years, but that’s exactly what the B17 is.

Quite simply, this is a premium saddle, and one of the best bike saddles for commuting. It’s wide enough to offer support on the daily commute, the leather is waterproof, it looks stylish, is handcrafted, comes with a 10 year guarantee and is extremely durable. Leather saddles might look uncomfortable, but it’s the rigidness that makes them so effective. They won’t yield or compress and will always offer you maximum support. Better still, leather moulds to the shape of your body over time, so you’ll end up with your own, personal saddle.

Brooks saddles are expensive but many cyclists consider them a worthy investment. They’re made using premium grade leather and the build quality is incredibly high. The result is a saddle that will last for at least ten years and potentially much longer. Since leather saddles mould to the body, owners are reluctant to replace them. Fortunately, with build quality this high, many find that they don’t have to. Brooks is a prestige brand with many imitators, so there are alternative choices if the price is too much.

Pros

• Rigid leather is very supportive
• Moulds to your shape
• High quality premium saddle

Cons

• Expensive
• Retro aesthetic isn’t to everyone’s taste
• A target for thieves

SHOP ON AMAZON

2. Fabric Cell Elite Radius

• £50
• $70
• €55

Prices are approximate

• Weight: 355g
• Width: 155mm
• Length: 282mm

Innovative pyramid cells distribute weight evenly

Foam doesn’t compress or become hard

A lightweight option

If the traditional style of the Brooks doesn’t appeal, then you’ll love the ultra-modern aesthetics of the Elite Radius. It’s substantially cheaper too, and about much than just looks. An innovative core of collapsible pyramid cells makes for unparalleled comfort.

The design is similar to that found inside running shoes. The air sprung interior distributes your weight across those pyramid cells, offering support and comfort in equal measure. The Elite Radius was designed specifically for the commute so the width is just right. Foam saddles sometimes have a habit of compressing and turning hard under pressure, but the air springs stop this from happening.

It’s light too, so it won’t add much additional weight to your bike. If you ride in an upright position then there’s little reason not to opt for the Elite Radius, but lower riders might want to look elsewhere. That said, if you’ve struggled with unwanted pressure points in the past, then the even weight distribution offered here will revolutionise your rides.

Pros

• Even weight distribution for great comfort
• Acts like memory foam
• Very light

Cons

• Not the best for lower riders
• Foam can get warm
• Doesn’t feel as durable as leather

Buy Here

3. Selle Italia ST7 Vision Superflow

• £73
• $80
• €85

Prices are approximate

• Weight: 480g
• Dimensions: 165 x 250 mm

Shock absorbers mean an extraordinarily smooth ride

Superflow keeps things cool

LED light

The ST7 is the only saddle on the list to come with shock absorbers for a truly luxurious ride. It’s capable of handling bumps and jolts with ease, leaving you with a smooth ride on even the busiest of commutes. If the roads around you aren’t in the best condition, this might be an ideal choice.

As well as those shock absorbers, the saddle comes with gel inserts for additional comfort. It also has an integrated LED for late-night commutes or the darker winter months. This safety device makes a big difference. The smooth ride, coupled with enhanced visibility, grants peace of mind.

So-called “Superflow” technology simply means that the saddle is well ventilated – it will stay cool not matter the distance of your commute. Much like the Elite Radius, this was also designed specifically for the daily commute. The level of comfort and shock absorption is enough to transform a ride and something well worth experiencing. Saddles this smooth almost feel as though you’re on a totally different bike!

Pros

• LED light
• One of the smoothest rides
• Well-ventilated

Cons

• Not the most “aero”
• Pricey

Buy Here

The post 3 Best Bike Saddles for Commuting [Find Your Perfect Seat] appeared first on Discerning Cyclist.

Brooks saddles are some of the most popular leather saddles on the market. Their premium quality comes at a high price, however. If you’re on a strict budget, or simply don’t think that the high cost is justified, fear not. There are some fantastic alternatives that won’t make a big dent in your wallet.

Price, quality of the leather, durability and comfort are all important when choosing a saddle. Here’s a rundown of our top 3 Brooks alternatives.

What is the Cheapest Brooks Saddle?

The cheapest Brooks saddles are the C15 and C17. Although these occupy the budget end of the range, they’ll still set you back £99.99, a price that some cyclists are simply unwilling to pay.

The C15 is a sports saddle built for riding on gravel and the road. It’s designed with fast touring in mind and it’s extremely flexible, perfect for a long ride. This saddle is also available carved for no additional cost. The C17 is a multipurpose saddle engineered to handle anything from touring to urban cycling. It’s only available as carved, with a hole to relieve pressure.

Why You Can Trust Us

Discerning Cyclist’s expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing cycling products so you don’t have to.

Testing stylish gear since 2012

Hundreds of hands-on product tests

Unfiltered opinions from experienced cyclists

Learn more about Discerning Cyclist here.

Best Brooks Saddle Alternatives [Top 3]

If those saddles are still above your price bracket or you want to shop around, there are plenty of high quality alternatives out there. Brooks saddles are certainly premium, but they’re far from the only stylish leather saddles available.

Best Leather Bike Saddle Under £50

1. BLB Fly X

Features:

Stylish, sophisticated design

Premium quality leather

Fully waterproof

Comes in two colours

Perfect if you prefer a minimalist look, the BLB Fly X comes in at £49.99 and it’s crafted from premium quality leather. This is a classy saddle more than capable of competing with Brooks in the style department. Its aesthetic harks back to vintage Italian designs.

Not only does the Fly X look more expensive than it is, but it also has a high quality build. Best of all (and just like a Brooks saddle) the leather will mould to your shape over time. This makes for an extremely comfortable ride and means that the saddle could feasibly last a lifetime. As with all leather saddles, the Fly X is waterproof, weatherproof and will help to prevent overheating.

You can choose classic tanned leather or black, but both saddles look great on the bike. They’re a perfect example of less being more. The streamlined, minimalistic look is sophisticated and a subtly embossed, golden logo adds the perfect finishing touch.

2. Cinelli Scatto

Features:

Eye catching and iconic design

High quality synthetic leather

Multipurpose

Pressure mapping

The Scatto saddle is a joy to behold! Cinelli saddles are popular around the world for their bright, vibrant and imaginative designs. If you want to stand out from the crowd with a premium quality leather saddle, this is your go-to option: these saddles are iconic!

The Scatto is an all purpose saddle that will see you through urban and off road journeys. It’s made using high quality leather that’s fully waterproof. Sweat wicks fast from the leather surface and the saddle will mould to your shape with time. Pressure mapping on the padding makes for an even more comfortable ride.

Although the style is a big departure from the more restrained Brooks saddle, Cinelli is loved by cyclists around the world. It’s crafted from synthetic leather and there are multiple designs to choose from. Whichever you pick, you can be sure of one thing: this saddle is a statement piece like no other.

3. PedalPro Classic

Features:

Incredibly cheap

Genuine leather

Shock absorbing springs

Retro aesthetic

If cost is your biggest motivating factor; look no further than the PedalPro Classic. Not only is this the cheapest option on the list by a substantial margin, but it’s one of the cheapest saddles you’ll find anywhere. Despite the price, it’s genuine leather.

The saddle also comes with shock absorption springs and it’s surprisingly high quality given the budget price. Of course, the aesthetic is strictly no frills but we do enjoy the minimalistic, vintage stylings of this saddle. If the Scatto is too loud for your tastes, then you’ll probably love the PedalPro.

Those three shock absorbing springs make for a comfortable ride across even rougher terrain, and the leather feels luxurious. Attaching the saddle is simple, too, and won’t take more than a few minutes. As budget offerings go, you can’t really go wrong here. You’ll struggle to find a genuine leather saddle any cheaper than the PedalPro.

The post Brooks Saddle Alternatives [3 Chic Budget Bike Seats] appeared first on Discerning Cyclist.

The Short Answer

Brooks saddles are highly regarded for their quality, comfort, and durability. Handcrafted in England with premium materials, these saddles offer a luxurious and comfortable ride. While they come with a higher price tag, their long lifespan and superior craftsmanship make them worth the investment for many cyclists.

Brooks England saddles have a reputation for being top of the range. The name itself conjures images of luxury, comfort, and saddles that last a lifetime. Quality materials and stylish designs make these saddles a tempting proposition for many cyclists.

Brooks is an old brand too, which adds to the sense of prestige. Of course, with such a reputation comes a high price tag and many will wonder – are Brooks saddles really worth it?

Read on to find out.

Are Brooks Saddles Made in England?

All Brooks saddles are made in England. They’re produced in Brooks’ West Midlands factory, the same one they’ve been using for over 150 years! Although it’s now owned by an Italian company, Brooks keeps its manufacturing in England. It’s one of the top English cycling brands, alongside Brompton.

Brooks was founded back in 1866 and still uses many of the same production methods. Its reputation as a heritage brand ensures quality materials and fantastic workmanship. The saddles have (of course) modernised over the years, but history still plays a large part in the Brooks brand identity, and every product is handcrafted.

Are Brooks Saddles Any Good?

Brooks saddles have a reputation for high quality, premium design, comfort and longevity. They’re some of the best saddles on the market and many cyclists swear by them. You also get a 10 year guarantee, proof of just how durable these saddles are.

The saddles are handcrafted with extraordinary attention to detail using durable, premium quality leather. They’re breathable and take the shape of the rider over time. If that wasn’t enough, they’re also versatile and suitable for any kind of cycling; from the daily commute to off road.

Are Brooks Saddles Comfortable?

The simple answer is yes! Brooks saddles are widely regarded as some of the most comfortable on the market. That’s owing to the leather build. There’s no chafing, sweat is quickly wicked away and the saddle moulds to its rider over time.

At first glance, these saddles don’t look as comfortable as they actually are. They don’t contain any gels or extra padding, but they’re comfortable precisely because they’re firm, offering plenty of support as you cycle. They offer such a pleasant ride, in fact, that Brooks has become a byword for comfort.

Can Brooks Saddles Get Wet?

As with any saddle, Brooks can get wet, but they won’t stay wet for long, absorb water or become “moist.” Leather saddles are exceptionally water resistant and any moisture quickly wicks away. The same applies to sweat, so your saddle will remain dry even on the longest ride.

Of course, if you’re caught in a torrent of rain it’s important to dry your saddle when you get home. Simply dabbing it with a towel and removing surface moisture will dramatically increase its lifespan. These saddles are expensive investments and should be treated as such.

If you’re happy to stray from the iconic leather seats then Brooks offer the Cambium C17 too. This flexible, vulcanised-rubber top seat is suitable for all rides, roads, and weathers.

Why Are Brooks Saddles So Popular?

Brooks saddles are popular because of their long history, reputation for quality and extreme comfort. The saddles have attained near mythological status in the cycling world and are considered the height of luxury.

The company has had a long time to build its reputation – it’s been making saddles for over 150 years. That’s given Brooks ample time to perfect their products, source quality materials and create a stylish design. It’s this combination of comfort and longevity and style that makes the saddles so enduringly popular.

Their iconic design puts them alongside other premium, fashionable riding gear. Being immediately recognisable inevitably boosts Brooks’ popularity.

Do Brooks Saddles Get Stolen?

As is the case with any expensive item, theft is always a danger. Saddles are one of the most commonly stolen parts of a bicycle (along with lights) so it pays to take precautions. Using a secondary lock, replacing quick release clamps and installing locking clamps all make a big difference.

That said, Brooks saddles aren’t any more vulnerable to theft than other products, although their price tag might make them more attractive to thieves. Cyclists should also be wary of buying second hand Brooks saddles. Since these saddles take time to break in, it’s unlikely that a cyclist would suddenly sell. Many second hand Brooks saddles are stolen.

Brooks Saddles Prices

As you might expect from such a premium name, Brooks saddles carry a hefty price tag. The cheapest C15 clocks in at around £99.99 while the top of the range B17 Special Titanium can set you back as much as £244.99. Clearly, this isn’t an investment to be taken lightly.

Brooks C15 Carved All-Weather Cambium Black

Check Price

Brooks England B17 Special Titanium Black

Check Price

You’ll pay about £129.99 for a midrange B17 or £135.99 for the touring Flyer. Brooks’ range is wide, with models to suit every style. Some come with additional suspension, others (like the B17 Special Brooks Lab) feature intricately carved designs. Whatever your riding style and aesthetic, Brooks has a saddle to match.

Brooks B17 Special Saddle, unisex adult, B 17...

Check Price

Brooks England FLYER HONEY

Check Price

Why Are Brooks Saddles So Expensive?

Brooks saddles are expensive because of the quality materials used, how comfortable they are and how long they last. These saddles come with a 10 year guarantee but most cyclists use them for much longer – in some cases even a lifetime. The heritage and prestige of the Brooks name also play a part.

As such, Brooks saddles are best considered a long term investment. You’re paying for an incredibly comfortable ride and a product that won’t need to be replaced for a long time. The initial price tag might be hard to swallow but it will eventually pay for itself. Cheaper saddles are often “false economy” since they’ll need to be replaced more frequently.

Are Brooks England Saddles Worth the Money?

Most cyclists consider Brooks saddles a worthwhile investment. Ride quality alone distinguishes these saddles from the crowd and justifies the cost. When you factor in that every saddle is handmade, will last for years and uses the highest quality materials, the cost suddenly doesn’t seem as high.

It becomes even less daunting if you look at Brooks saddles as an investment. The comfort and build quality on offer here are virtually unparalleled. Of course, saddle preference is ultimately a matter of taste, but you’ll struggle to find many cyclists who regret purchasing a Brooks.

Brooks England Pros and Cons

The post Are Brooks Saddles Worth It? [PROS + CONS] appeared first on Discerning Cyclist.

For a long time women’s saddles didn’t exist, making it harder and less accessible for women to ride bikes comfortably.

Times have thankfully now changed and our list of saddles will help support comfortable riding for all women, something everyone deserve.

In this guide, we’ll take a look at what makes a comfy saddle as well as helping find the most comfortable bike saddle for women.

5 Comfy Picks

Do Women Need Different Bike Saddles?

Many women will feel that they need a different saddle to the ones that come as standard on their bicycle. This is because most bicycles come with saddles that tend to be basic and orientated towards male anatomical needs.

Moreover, it’s really important to note that although women’s anatomy differs, male and female anatomy is of course very different, thus demanding a difference in needs regarding saddle comfort and suitability. 

Men’s vs Women’s Saddle

First and foremost, men’s saddles do tend to be overall narrower. This is because male sit bones tend to be slightly narrower than women’s in general. Additionally, men’s saddles also tend to have a longer nose as men often sit more towards the front of the saddle. 

On the other hand, women’s saddles tend to be wider and more padded in order to offer more support towards the back as women tend to sit towards the back. Women’s saddles will often have a shorter nose as well to relieve pressure that longer saddles would otherwise cause. 

Therefore, overall women often need more support on their sit bones and pressure relieving aspects for soft tissue, unlike men who often sit more towards the front of the saddle.

Why Do Women’s Bike Saddle Have Holes? 

Many women’s saddles now have cut outs in the middle or at the front. This is a popular feature which helps to prevent numbness by promoting blood flow when riding in the saddle.

Additionally, the holes also benefit women as it helps prevent weight being predominantly on their highly sensitive soft tissue, thus allowing women to sit more towards the front of their saddle: something many women find far too painful to do.

How Do You Choose a Saddle?

The best way to choose a saddle would firstly include figuring out the type of riding you would like to use the saddle for, then the width of your sit bones. Then I’d highly recommend testing different ones out.

Many bike shops, brand and online retailers will allow customers to test saddles out for around 30 days. This period of time should help you to identity which saddle best suits you before fully committing to one. 

Are Wide Saddles More Comfortable? 

Wide saddles can offer more support for your bottom and sit bones, however they can be too wide for you personally. As previously mentioned, everyone has different sized bodies so it’s best to test the saddles out.

However, if you do have wider sit bones a wider saddle will be far more comfortable in comparison to a narrower saddle. This will improve comfort, reduce bottom numbness and improve your power transfer. 

Can It Be Too Wide? 

Saddles can be too wide, this is dependent on the individual’s sit bone width and personal needs. But, people are all built differently and like many things will therefore need a different width to suit their needs.

However, sit bones can surprise you: they don’t necessarily correlate with your weight and instead are a specific width for each individual.

How Wide Should It Be?

Your saddle should be as wide as you want or as wide as your sit bones. To be specific, a measurement can be taken, from home following a video tutorial, or in most bike shops using a simple (or sometimes complex) device.

When measuring sit bones, a foam like seat is placed on a hard surface to sit on. Once sat on it will create two indentations. The measurement is then taken from the middle of each indentation, thus revealing the width of the saddle that is most suitable.

Why You Can Trust Us

Discerning Cyclist’s expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing cycling products so you don’t have to.

Testing stylish gear since 2012

Hundreds of hands-on product tests

Unfiltered opinions from experienced cyclists

Learn more about Discerning Cyclist here.

Most Comfortable Bike Seats for Women

1. Specialized Power Comp with Mimic

• £80
• $140

Prices are approximate

Mimic multilayered foam

Versatile sizing options

Overcoming saddle issues

This saddle has put women’s comfort as well as overcoming saddle issues at the forefront of the in depth patented Body Geometry design process.

The Comp Mimic uses innovative Mimic multilayered foam to comfortably support and maintain equilibrium and minimise swelling to delicate soft tissue. Therefore allowing any position on the saddle to be possible – yes, even sitting towards the nose!

Additionally, this saddle also comes in three different sizes which are: 143mm, 155mm and 168mm, therefore supporting a range of sizes and needs. Overall, this is a great option for any female rider, especially commuters, who want versatility and comfort in a sleek saddle.

buy here

2. ISM PL 1.0

• £200

Prices are approximate

Better blood flow

PL 1.0 saddle for long-range performance

Comfort for hours in the saddle

ISM is a popular brand of saddles among both female and male riders and are known for their interesting design. For example, instead of having a cut out, the nose of the ISM has two prongs to sit on, allowing for better blood flow and therefore less numbness and more comfort.

This is a great option for female riders doing a lot of riding such as commuting or road riding, the PL 1.0 (which replaced the ISM Podium) is from the performance long range which has been specifically designed for hours in the saddle.

Although this is a very comfortable saddle, it is only available in the one width size, but due to the positioning should be suitable for all sit bones. Although this saddle takes a little getting used to at first, due to its unique design, it is overall a great saddle for those doing hours in the saddle.

buy here

Best for Plus Size Females 

3. Liv Contact Comfort Plus

• £40
• $50

Prices are approximate

Contact Comfort Plus

Optimal comfort

Pressure-relieving design

Liv is a female oriented brand that was created by Giant in order to focus efforts on creating the best products to suit all types of female riders needs, and their saddles are no exception to this.

The Contact Comfort Plus has been designed with optimal comfort in mind which is aided by the central cut out to reduce pressure and numbness of female soft tissue, pressure relieving D2 base and generous padding.

Also, the saddle is slightly wider than the other saddles, measuring a width of 169mm, meaning that it is a great option for those wanting a little extra comfort and support when sitting in the saddle.

buy here

Most Comfortable for Older Women

4. Specialized Expedition

• £35
• $50

Prices are approximate

Sit bone protection

Upright riding position suitability

Wide size for all needs

The Specialized Expedition women’s saddle is a great option for women who are a little older who may want comfort and sit bone protection from a saddle. This saddle will also suit more upright riding positions, therefore will be perfect for city bikes and hybrids.

Overall, the Specialized Expedition saddle mainly consists of a gel pad, which offers a great amount of comfort for bones and soft tissue in comparison to thinner more ‘road style’ saddles, which tend to have far less padding.

Although this saddle is only available in the one size, because it’s already very wide it should be more than wide enough to cater to everyone’s needs and provide comfort for sore sit bones that have had enough of painful pedalling.

buy here

5. Fizik Luce S-Alloy

• £95
• $99
• €99

Prices are approximate

Cut-out design for soft tissue discomfort

Wider sitting area for better support

Two size options (145mm and 155mm)

 

Italian based Fikiz have been a firm favorite among many cyclists for their saddles. The women’s Luce S-Alloy has a a cut out in the middle to reduce soft tissue discomfort and a wider sitting area at the back for support.

Moreover, the Luce S-Alloy comes in two sizes which are 145mm (regular) and 155mm (large) allowing for customers to select the one best suited to themselves. Towards the nose the saddle narrows in order to improve weight distribution and reduce friction around the thigh area for optimal comfort.

Interestingly, Fizik also have their own virtual bike shopping feature where a questionnaire helps to determine their recommended perfect saddle for you. A really helpful feature for those who don’t want to trawl through saddles before finding the one.

buy here

How Can I Make My Bike Saddle Less Painful?  

First and foremost, the most cost effective solution to make your bike saddle less painful would be to buy a gel saddle cover. This simply fastens around your current saddle to make it more squishy and comfortable. 

Next, another solid solution would be to invest in a comfy pair of padded short / padded liners. The extra support from the chamois in either will make a huge difference for your overall comfort. 

What Helps a Sore Bum from Cycling? 

Undercarriage discomfort from broken, irritated or chafed skin can be eased by investing in a PH friendly chamois cream to use while riding and a nappy rash style cream post-ride to treat the sore area. This may sound bizarre but it does work very effectively.

However, in the long run riding will get easier this is because your body, especially your sit bones and skin, become accustom to the positionining in the saddle. Therefore, the pain will thankfully more than likely subside. Just like wearing-in a new pair of shoes.

Read More:

• Best Gel Bikes Seats
• Safest Bike Helmets for Commuting

The post Most Comfortable Bike Seat for Women: Top 5 Comfy Saddles appeared first on Discerning Cyclist.

Small in size, but huge in importance, no keen cyclist should ever underestimate how critical a role a bike seat clamp in deterring pesky thieves.

Read More:

• Best Folding Bike Locks
• Sold Secure DIAMOND: The New Standard for Bike Locks

Even though you may only notice them when adjusting your saddle, they are essential in the way they ‘clamp’ down on the seat tube, holding the seat post in place and stopping the saddle from rotating or the post from sinking into the frame.

Here, we’ll look at how to secure a bicycle seat, as well as going through four of the best seat clamps currently on the market:

TOP TIP: Don’t Use Quick-Release Clamps!

If your bike seat is secured with a quick-release skewer clamp, it’s a question of when – not if – your saddle will be stolen.

Anyone can walk up to your bike and take your seat in a matter of seconds without any tools.

How to Prevent Your Bike Seat from Being Stolen

• Non-quick release seat clamp – any opportunistic seat thief would be out of luck – any potential seat-stealer would need to have their tools on them to remove the saddle. These usually come in two forms: Allen key seat clamps, which can be retrofitted to almost any bike, and Nut & Bolt saddle clamps, which are more common among children’s bicycles or cheaper models.
• Locking seat clamp – offer even more protection, given they need a manufacturer-specific tool to release the seat clamp, making it harder and longer to remove the saddle.

Why You Can Trust Us

Discerning Cyclist’s expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing cycling products so you don’t have to.

Testing stylish gear since 2012

Hundreds of hands-on product tests

Unfiltered opinions from experienced cyclists

Learn more about Discerning Cyclist here.

Top 4 Anti-Theft Bike Seat Tools

Bike Security Skewers

Replacing quick-release skewers with security skewers is the most common way to protect your bike.

It certainly prevents thieves from being able to steal your seat with their bare hands, but if they have the right type of hex key with anti-theft pin hole, they can still quite quickly make off with your seat or bike wheels.

Bike Skewer Tip:

If you use a bike wheel skewer, fill glue into the skewer head so it can’t easily be released. When you need to take it off yourself, simply put nail varnish remover on it, and the glue will dissipate.

1. CyclingDeal

• £20

Prices are approximate

• 100 mm front hub
• 130 – 135 mm rear hub
• 28 – 32 mm bike seat post clamp

Bike anti-theft skewers

Quick-release design

Five-sided lock

Kicking us off are these three-piece quick-release bike anti-theft skewers, which come with a five-sided lock to stave off thieves when your back is turned from your bicycle.

Made of durable steel, this bike skewer lock is easy to install and offer extra comfort and security that most quick-release designs don’t provide.

Quick to set up and dependable for a long time, they also provide excellent value for money under £20.

SHOP ON AMAZON

Gravity Bolts and Clamps

These are a type of bike skewer that can only be used if the bike is turned upside down.

So, if you lock your bike in a way that keeps it upright, the seat clamp bolt can’t be taken off. But, when/if you need to change your seat position (or a tyre – as it also works to protect bicycle wheels), it’s not hard for you to release it when needed.

2. Abus Nutfix Locking M5 Seatpost Clamp

• £30

Prices are approximate

• Striking orange design
• Made of sturdy, durable steel
• Perfect for city bikes

Locking seat post bolt

Abus bike saddle clamp

Anti-theft mechanism

If you prefer a locking seat post bolt, look no further than this Abus bike saddle clamp, available in a more aesthetically pleasing orange, too.

A great choice for commuters or urban cyclists, the ‘nut’ is fitted with a mechanism that only releases the screw below when the bike is on its side, making it impossible to access the screw otherwise.

If the bike is locked upright, the Nutfix can’t be removed, thus preventing access to the ‘nut’, giving you just the sort of peace of mind you’re craving.

SHOP ON AMAZON

Reusable Secure Zip Ties

These are an environmentally-friendly alternative to the plastic defences you will more commonly find, and take less time and effort to release, too.

To reuse zip ties, simply push back the locking mechanism with something pointed, like a pin, pencil or a pair of scissors. They are not only built to last, but are particularly durable, too.

3. Hiplok Z LOK

• £15

Prices are approximate

• Lightweight design
• Flexible, tough nylon outer design
• Multi-use and reusable

Flexible nylon outer

Multi-use security ties

Vibrant color options

Weighing a mere 20g (including its key), you’ll do well to find a lighter bike lock than this Hiplok design, available in an array of colours including lime, orange and red.

Don’t be fooled into thinking it isn’t tough enough, though – its flexible, solid nylon outer complements its reinforced steel core and locking head perfectly and is more than enough to put off potential thieves.

Plus, it has the luxury of being made of multi-use, reusable security ties – perfect for short cycles, such as city commutes.

SHOP ON AMAZON

Bike Seat Lock

These are either ‘normal locks’ you can run through your bike seat to keep it in place, or alternatively, a bike seat bolt that doubles up as a lock for your entire bike. As you’ll see below:

4. Seatylock Comfort

• Saddle turns into a solid block easily
• Ultra-strong chain for most reliable protection
• Ergonomic, lightweight saddle

Virtually impenetrable

Ergonomic and lightweight

Top lockable bike saddle

Finally, for your more typical variation of bike saddle locks, this SEATYLOCK design is a virtually impenetrable bicycle seat lock which turns into a solid block to keep thieves at bay.

With an indestructible chain, nobody will be breaking into to this saddle, which also boasts an ergonomic, lightweight design tailor-made for riders who prioritise agility as they cycle.

For more bike locks, be sure to check out our run-through of top lockable bike saddles here.

SHOP ON AMAZON

Read More:

• Stylish Helmets for Commuters
• Brightest LED Headlights for Bikes
• Best Bike Chain Cleaning Tools

The post Best Bike Seat Clamps [Top 4 Anti-Theft Devices for Your Saddle] appeared first on Discerning Cyclist.